Two months ago, we lamented on how the economic recovery of the Great Recession had become officially much slower than that of the Great Depression. Last week, the Bureau of Economic Analysis released an advance estimate of the GDP growth rate for the second quarter of 2018. The good news? It's finally at 4.1%, a rate not seen since the third quarter of 2014.
On a Nominal GDP Per Capita basis, the economic recovery of the Great Recession is still way ahead of the Great Depression. The dip in nominal GDP per capita was really shallow - less than 3 percentage points. The drop in GDP per capita during the Great Depression was a catastrophic 47%.
At this point in the economic recovery, some eleven years after the Great Recession started, we are almost 30% better than where we were. Where as during the Great Depression, nominal GDP per capita remained almost 10% below the depression's inception.
In terms of real GDP per capita, people were made whole only on 2013 of the Great Recession. Five years later, we are only 12% better than where we were in 2013. During the Great Depression, people were only made whole, in terms of Real GDP Per Capita, only on year 10 of the Great Depression. But the recovery accelerated even faster. Just one year later, people were 8% better. That trend will accelerate in year 12 - by then, they will be almost 18% better than they were just one year earlier. Now where will we be one year from now? We don't know. So far, we are faring better than people of the Great Depression, but just barely.
We've all seen this chart. Next to New Zealand, Australia has one of the most overheated real estate markets in the entire world.
As of March 2018, Australian Home Prices have appreciated more than 83% above where they would be on an inflation-adjusted basis.
But which is the most overheated real estate market in Australia? It's definitely not Sydney. As it turns out, Sydney's price appreciation is below average. That honor goes to Melbourne, closely followed by Darwin, with Hobart and Perth fast catching up.
Amazingly, Darwin peaked way back in June 2014 - four years ago. It is now down more than 17% from that peak. The same holds true for Perth. Those markets have been in correction mode for years. At it's peak, Darwin home prices appreciated a full 156 percentage points above inflation. As of March 2018, the inflation gap for Darwin is down to only 99%. With an inflation gap of 117%, Melbourne is now the undisputed champion of unaffordable Australian real estate.
How about Sydney? Sydney's inflation gap is only 66%, substantially lower than the Eight City average of 77%.
If Filipinos are getting richer, why are there fewer and fewer Filipino students studying in the USA every year?
According to the latest Open Doors Report,
the number of Filipino students studying in US Colleges and
Universities, at 3,066 students in 2016, is even lower than what it was
in the year 2000: 3,139 students. However, this is a 4.16% increase over the previous year's total of 2,886 students.
This runs counter to the trend in the ASEAN. Other ASEAN countries,
particularly Vietnam, have been enrolling more and more of their
students in US Colleges and Universities.
Almost
all countries discussed in this blog post, with the exception of
Thailand, have been experiencing rapid growth in home prices that have
outstripped inflation by a wide margin. The gap between home prices and
their inflation adjusted levels are at the widest ever, particularly in
Singapore, Hong Kong, and the Philippines.
Singapore
Singapore's
home prices which have been declining for fourteen straight quarters,
have resumed their upward trend. Home prices have rebounded by 5.46% off
the low of 166.15 as of the first quarter of 2018. However, home
prices are still 75.22% above their year-end 2004 levels. Overall
prices levels, as measured by inflation have just increased by 31.45% since year end 2004. In other words, for the past ten years,
Singaporean home prices have outpaced inflation by almost than 40
percentage points.
Malaysia
Neighboring
Malaysia's House Price Index now stands at 270.70 as of the fourth quarter 2017, 170.70% higher than year-end 1998 levels. General price
levels as of the fourth quarter 2017 are only around 54.89% higher than
their year-end 1998 levels.
Thailand In Thailand,
which has been experiencing political turmoil for some time, home prices
have remained essentially flat since the end of 2004. Home Prices ended
2013 with the index at 100.54, just 0.54% higher than the end of 2004,
but showing a substantial recovery since the recent low of 74.08 posted
in the third quarter of 2009. In the first quarter of 2018, home prices
have rebounded to 122.61, or 22.61% higher than its year-end 2004
levels, way below its expected inflation adjusted levels. General Price
levels are 35.20% above their year-end 2004 levels. In other words,
Thailand Home Prices have lagged inflation by as much as 12.59% since
their year-end 2004 levels.
Indonesia Meanwhile in
Indonesia, home prices have showed no signs of slowing down their upward
trajectory. In fact, prices seem to have gone parabolic, climbing
4.63% in the last quarter of 2013, from a base of 121.49 as of the third
quarter of 2013 to 127.11 as of year end 2013. In the first quarter of
2018, home prices have climbed an additional 25.47% to reach 152.58.
Since the first quarter of 2007, home prices have risen 52.58%, while
inflation has raised general prices by 84.21% during the same period.
Indonesian Home Prices, like Thailand, have lagged inflation since 2007.
Hong Kong
Hong Kong real
estate prices have reached a
staggering 446.68 as of the first quarter of 2018 from a base of 100
since year-end 2004. General inflation levels have just climbed 47.18%
during this same period. In other words, Hong Kong home prices have
outpaced inflation by an astounding 29.50% during this period, the
highest rate of appreciation in the countries covered in this post.
However, it is
important to note that Hong Kong Home Prices have also entered into a
minor correction phase, declining by 9.83% from its recent peak of 365.95 as
of the third quarter of 2015 to just 329.38 as of the first quarter of
2016. Although there was a distinct possibility that Hong Kong Home Prices entered a bear market just as it did in the aftermath of the 1997
Asian Financial Crisis, that possibility has now disappeared and the index is at an all-time high. See previous post: How low can Hong Kong Property Prices Go? Some Clues from the Not Too Distant Past
Philippines
Philippine
house price index stands at 248.31 at the end of the first quarter 2018
or over 148.31% above their year-end 2004 levels. Philippine home
prices, with the exception of Hong Kong, have posted the largest 10-year
gains among all the countries considered in this blog post. Like
Singapore and Malaysia, Philippine home prices have outstripped
inflation by around seventy-eight percentage points. Like Indonesia and Hong
Kong, Philippine home prices have so far no signs of slowing down their
upward trajectory for the foreseeable future. The question is, is this
momentum sustainable? Or will the Philippines and Indonesia follow its
ASEAN neighbors, Singapore, Malaysia, and Thailand, in exhibiting
plateauing or declining house prices? That remains to be seen.
There's no doubt about it. The economic decline of the Great Depression was extremely severe. Nominal
GDP per capita decline by almost 50% during the Great Depression versus
a slightly more than 2% decline in Nominal GDP per capita during the
Great Recession. Eleven years after the start of the Great Depression, Nominal GDP per capita was still almost 10% lower. In the Great Recession, it is 27.01% higher.
However, economic growth rates during the Great Depression were much more robust than that of the Great Recession, both on an absolute basis and on a per capita basis.
In truth, the economic recovery of the Great Recession has been almost
imperceptible to most Americans. On a per capita bais, real GDP per
Capita grew by 7.66% in the past eleven years - or roughly a compounded
annual average growth rate of only 0.67% per annum. This is far less
than the so-called "Hindu Rate of Growth" threshold of 1.30% per annum. This growth rate is so slow that it is almost imperceptible.
In 2018, something extraordinary happened. Those who survived the Great
Depression in 1940 (eleven years after the onset of the Great
Depression) will be substantially better of than the survivors of the
Great Recession in 2018. Real GDP Per Capita for Great Recession
survivors would have grown by another anemic 0.67% per annum in 2018.
But for survivors of the Great Depression era, their incomes per capita
would have grown by an astounding 7.75% in just one year. Moreover, that
trend will only accelerate in the next three years. By 1943, Great
Depression survivors will be almost 56% richer than they were in 1940.
Can we expect the same for survivors of the Great Recession in the next three years? It's possible but not probable.
Last May 4, 2015,
we noted that Construction Gross Value (Construction GV) at 11.21% as
of the year-end 2014 was already well above its historical average of
9.59% of GDP since 1990. This ratio has run at an above average rate
since 2009 and has already eaten away at the "cumulative underhang" or
underinvestment in construction that has taken place since 2004, when
the excessive investment in construction that took place in the mid to
late 1990's was being absorbed.
As of the 1st
Qtr of 2018, Construction GV as a percentage of GDP now stands higher at
12.08% of GDP - down from an all-time high of 12.61% posted in 2016. But the real
story is that Cumulative Construction GV has gone well above equilibrium
and now stands at 6.0% above equilibrium. Given all the planned new projects that are already at
the execution stage, the momentum in Construction Investment will
continue.
It's no secret that a higher minimum wage is a hot button political issue these days. Just ask Bernie Sanders and his fight for a $15 per hour federal minimum wage, more than double what it is now: $7.25 per hour. The minimum wage has been stuck at that level since 2010, eight years ago. But the minimum wage has been stagnating not just for years at a time but for decades.
The federal minimum wage used to increase almost lock step with labor productivity until it decoupled sometime in the late 60's. Had the minimum wage kept up with labor productivity, the minimum wage would now be an astounding $19.33 per hour, as calculated by the Economic Policy Institute. This is almost 170% above current levels.
We recalculated EPI's chart and arrived at similar numbers: $19.06 per hour for 2017.
As a result of this stagnation, labor's contribution to GDP has been in steady decline. Labor as a share of GDP peaked at 66% in 1970. Today that ratio stands at just 60%, slightly higher than the multi-decade low of 59% in 2010.
A person working at minimum wage for 40 hours a week, 4 weeks per month, 12 months per year - in other words, pretty much all the time with no vacation, save for weekends - would earn just $13,920 per year or just 10% above the federal poverty levels of $12,140 for an individual. Obviously, a person working at minimum wage would not be able to sustain himself for very long.
"many working adults must seek public assistance and/or hold multiple jobs in order to afford to feed, clothe, house, and provide medical care for themselves and their families."
This reliance on public assistance puts a strain on public finances and amounts to a generous subsidy for corporations. It has become so pervasive that large corporations constantly route their workers to such programs or mount Thanksgiving collection drives for their employees.
MIT's Living Wage Calculator has calculated the living wage for every state, county, and major metropolitan area. Nationally, it estimates the living wage to be $16.07 per hour in 2017, around 7% higher than the $15 per hour minimum wage that most labor activists are asking for.
On a state by state basis, the living wage for each states ranges from a low of $10.03 per hour in South Dakota to a high of $17.11 for the District of Columbia.
MIT 2017 Living Wage
By State
In US$ per Hour
State
MIT Living Wage
Federal Poverty Wage
Federal Minimum Wage
Alabama
$11.14
$5.00
$7.25
Alaska
$12.48
$7.00
$9.84
Arizona
$11.22
$5.00
$10.50
Arkansas
$10.38
$5.00
$8.50
California
$14.01
$5.00
$11.00
Colorado
$12.47
$5.00
$10.20
Connecticut
$12.88
$5.00
$10.10
Delaware
$12.44
$5.00
$8.25
District of Columbia
$17.11
$5.00
$12.50
Florida
$11.75
$5.00
$8.25
Georgia
$11.93
$5.00
$7.25
Hawaii
$15.39
$6.00
$10.10
Idaho
$10.64
$5.00
$7.25
Illinois
$12.50
$5.00
$8.25
Indiana
$10.70
$5.00
$7.25
Iowa
$10.53
$5.00
$7.25
Kansas
$10.69
$5.00
$7.25
Kentucky
$10.49
$5.00
$7.25
Louisiana
$10.91
$5.00
$7.25
Maine
$11.60
$5.00
$10.00
Maryland
$14.62
$5.00
$9.25
Massachusetts
$13.39
$5.00
$11.00
Michigan
$10.87
$5.00
$9.25
Minnesota
$11.53
$5.00
$9.65
Mississipi
$10.86
$5.00
$7.25
Missouri
$10.76
$5.00
$7.85
Montana
$10.95
$5.00
$8.30
Nebraska
$10.60
$5.00
$9.00
Nevada
$10.94
$5.00
$8.25
New Hampshire
$12.01
$5.00
$7.25
New Jersey
$13.72
$5.00
$8.60
New Mexico
$10.98
$5.00
$7.50
New York
$14.42
$5.00
$10.40
North Carolina
$11.36
$5.00
$7.25
North Dakota
$10.89
$5.00
$7.25
Ohio
$10.47
$5.00
$8.30
Oklahoma
$10.52
$5.00
$7.25
Oregon
$12.48
$5.00
$10.25
Pennsylvania
$11.11
$5.00
$7.25
Rhode Island
$12.10
$5.00
$10.10
South Carolina
$11.17
$5.00
$7.25
South Dakota
$10.03
$5.00
$8.85
Tennessee
$10.44
$5.00
$7.25
Texas
$11.03
$5.00
$7.25
Utah
$11.22
$5.00
$7.25
Vermont
$12.32
$5.00
$10.50
Virginia
$13.86
$5.00
$7.25
Washington
$12.28
$5.00
$11.50
West Virginia
$10.68
$5.00
$8.75
Wisconsin
$11.03
$5.00
$7.25
Wyoming
$10.63
$5.00
$7.25
National USA
$12.08
$5.01
$8.71
When weighted by the Civilian Noninstitutional Population of each state, the National Living Wage amounts to $12.08 per hour while the weighted average federal minimum wage amounts to $8.71 per hour.